A Simple Blót for Freyr (and others) Building Right Relationship: Part 1 A More Personal Heathenry BREAKING NEWS: Texas House bill could prevent Heathens from fostering or adopting children Skaði’s Protection: A prayer for troubled times Fun With Eggs: Celebrating Oschdre Handspinning for Beginners – Finishing Your Yarn A blurb from a Scandinavian on Vikings! Book Review: “The Basics of Heathenry: For Kids” By Jennifer Lohr Anterior líder de Bifrost Stine Helen Skår Buscando Establecer Lazos Oficiales Con La Asociación Yggdrasil de Costa Rica Bifrost’s Former Leader Stine Helen Skår Looking to Establish Official Relations With Yggdrasil Association of Costa Rica The Rational Heathen: Honoring Ancestors: Do I Really Have to Worship Aunt Mabel? Então você quer ser um heathen Why Heathenry is Awesome: A Detailed List Folkish owned company takes stand against racism Book Review: “Norse Mythology” By Neil Gaiman History Channel’s “Vikings” has gone down hill. Loki in Fjölvinsmál: Lævateinn and Lýr Paying the Price Arizona man files suit against The Asatru Community, Heathen Talk Network, and The Troth Making Your Own Butzemann So you want to pronounce Old Norse names… Ranting Recon: ¿Cuáles son las festividades Heathen? Equality and Gender in Heathenry So you want to be a Heathen The (Other) Most Wonderful Time of the Year The Rational Heathen: Is it Time to Abandon the Irminsul? The Ancestors as Bridges Instead of Barriers Asatru Means Faith, Not Hate Heathen Spirituality Heathens Deface Historic German Landmark The Last Breath of the Old Year Exceptionally rare buckle discovered with possible depictions of Loki My Vision for Heathenry Handspinning for Beginners – Plying Yarn 12 Devotional Days of Yule The Sacred Duty of Food The Skirnismal: How (And Why) Freyr Won Gerd Canadian Heathens Spearhead Pagan Declaration Lusse – Midwife of the Sun The Rational Heathen: Getting B!%¢#-Slapped by the Gods [NSFW] Fast-growing Swedish Asatru org exposed Rare Bronze Age Petroglyph Discovered in Denmark Heathens Around The World Take a Stand With Standing Rock Sioux A Heathen’s Journey to Devotional Polytheism Over 200 Oath Rings Just Discovered in Sweden Sigyn: Lady of Oblation and Victory Alvablot and Winternights Declaration 127 The Rational Heathen: Blood Sacrifices and Other Moronic Things The Reconstructionist Method O maior inimigo de Odin – Depressão no contexto Heathen The Rational Heathen: Women’s Role in Cultures Women In Heathenry: Their Words Women in Heathenry Grief and Loss in a Heathen Context A Dedication Contract for Freya São Paulo, A Thriving Hub of Heathenry? Handspinning for Beginners – Starting to Spin Celebrating the Feast of Zisa Michigan Heathen Runs For US Congress Building a Stronger Community The Rational Heathen: When Did the AFA Join the Westboro Baptist Church? Freyja Detroit Harvest Festival: How Some Heathens Are Giving Back To Their Community Urglaawe: One of History’s Best-Kept Secrets How To Write Old Norse In Runes Is Heathenry Really Missing Something? Writer’s Block from a Heathen Perspective The Real Story Behind ‘Camp Courage’ And The AFA Offerings for the Gods, Part 3: The Jotnar New Leadership Takes A.F.A In More Bigoted Direction What You Reap is What You Sow Offerings for the Gods, Part 2: The Vanir Creating Sacred Space Freyr isn’t going to Bless those PopTarts The Younger Futhark Runes: An Instructive Guide Approaching the Gods: Building The Vé “What is Valhalla, and who goes there?” The Rational Heathen: Can a Heathen Follow Christ? Deconstructing the Brisingamen Myth Urglaawe – An Introduction The Elder Futhark Runes: An Instructive Guide Heathen Families’ Summer Camp Offerings for the Gods, Part 1: The Aesir ¿Tenían los vikings tótems animales? Did the Vikings Have Totem Animals? Teaching Heathenry to my Kids Odin’s Greatest Enemy, Depression in a Heathen Context Where Strong Gods Are Found Tales of Ragnarök Hail Frigga What is Forn Sed? Everyday Heathenry: Making Midsummer Heathen Marriage: Anatomy of an Oath A Step In The Right Direction? T.A.C. Takes Action. The Rational Heathen: So, What IS a Heathen, Exactly? Heathenry is a Religion of Questions Handspinning For Beginners – Pre-Drafting and Drafting Fiber Ranting Recon: Becoming The Beast

Is Heathenry Incomplete?


Cara Freyasdaughter is a devotional polytheist dedicated to Freya and Freyr who works within a "reconstructed-ish" Heathen tradition. A current member of The Troth and ADF, she writes a biweekly blog on Patheos' Agora channel called "Happily Heathen". She also blogs regularly about her experiences as a polytheist at "A Community of Gods Surround Me" (communityofgods.wordpress.com). Currently, Cara leads Heathen rituals and Runes 'n Lore classes for the White Oak Grove CUUPs group in northern Illinois. She is also one of the founders of the Bay Area group the Vanic Conspiracy and the organizer of the Freyja’s Aett ritual group, which is devoted to Freya in all of her facets.

Heathenry, in all of its many forms, is a reconstructed (or “reconstructed-ish”) religion. As Heathens, we’re essentially taking as much as we can about what Ancient Heathens did and said and bringing it forward to guide our own religious and spiritual practices. Some Heathens stick as close to the information found in the sagas and eddas as they can; other Heathens are inspired by the materials in these resources but do not attempt to use any idea or belief verbatim. Whichever side of the Heathen spectrum we fall on, however, we all have the same basic problem: we only have a limited amount of information to go on. This being the case, how can we recreate full, living Heathen religion?

There’s been several very good, thoughtful articles this year about whether Modern Heathenry is complete that have provided much food for thought. Dagulf Loptson, a longtime Heathen and member of the Troth writing on Polytheist.com, points out that as we are a reconstructed religion with no “unbroken living tradition”, such as perhaps may exist with Santeria or Judaism, there is much that we’re missing. I agree with him in this for the most part. We are particularly missing those aspects of the religion than can’t be preserved in material culture, like songs and dances. In addition, because in the Old Norse and Germanic cultures, writing was not used to record myths or histories or to create literary works of any kind, and nothing was written down by them or their contemporaries, we only have a limited amount of written material to go on as well. (Snorri, a Christian writing maybe 300 years later, doesn’t count as a contemporary.)

While the source material may be much older, the remnants we have are limited by a number of factors: 1) what Snorri and his contemporaries knew about; 2) what of that Snorri and his contemporaries decided to record; 3) of that, what we in the modern world have found, 4) and then translated into English; and 5) that unless you have put in the time and effort to read and discuss all of the lore than has been translated into English, you’re limited to what those other scholars have decided to share with a larger audience. Even then, we may be missing some crucial details; the scholar’s interpretations of the surviving evidence is always changing. For example, we now know that many of those skeletons buried in “warrior’s graves” were actually women and not, as previously assumed, “small men”. (This sheds a whole new light on the concept of the shield maiden; just sayin’.)

However, not all is lost. From the Voluspa (“The Prophesy of the Seeress”, from the Poetic Edda), we get a fairly detailed example of a ritual and the technique (and cultural attitudes) around the practice of spae (“far seeing”). From the Gesta Danorum (“The History of the Danes”), by Saxo Grammaticus (which includes the material that was the basis for Hamlet as well as the story of Ragnar Lodbrok), we get information on what kind of offerings each deity was given. The Havamal also lists various “charms”, though the specifics of how to work these charms are not included. Also, we have several Anglo-Saxon resources, such as the Leechbook, which list spells for various needs and ailments. So we are not completely at a loss when it comes to the magical, spiritual, and religious practices from back in the day.

The question then becomes how much of the specific details and non-material culture do we really need to reconstruct the basic Heathen belief system and practices? Alyxander Folmer, creator of HHH (and also the husband of a rabbi), wrote this response to Dagulf’s article. First, he points out that even those cultures which seem to have a long, unbroken history (such as Judaism) have themselves changed quite a bit over the years. Modern Judaism, in all of its forms today, doesn’t look at all like the Temple-era Judaism of 2000+ years ago. All things change over time, including components of culture such as religious customs and languages.

Secondly, he points out that we have a living religion–people have been holding blots, worshiping the gods, making offerings and sacrifices, and creating songs and dances and rituals that work for us, here in the modern day, for over thirty years now. We are having discussions online and in person about how to do this thing called Heathenry and make it work for us. As such, it’s really a challenge to be a solitary Heathen. This isn’t Wicca; it’s hard to be a solitary practitioner and attempt to reconstruct what is essentially a tribal religion. Even if the only community you can find is online rather than in person, that’s still considerably better than trying to walk this path alone.

So, to go back to the initial question of this article: is Heathenry lacking anything that we can’t that we can’t reconstruct or create ourselves? I don’t think so. While it would certainly be a whole lot easier if we did have a living tradition to pull from, where all of these songs, dances, practices, and beliefs were already known and fully entrenched into our day-to-day lives, for me, personally, the Heathen practice I have practice I have now is very fulfilling. It’s fulfilling in no small part because I took to time to find out what I needed and what worked for me: I took a lot of time (and continue to put in a lot of time and effort) into reaching out to other Heathens and other Pagans or Polytheists who have gone through similar struggles, to share thoughts and ideas and find things that work for my Heathen practice. If Heathenry incomplete, in my opinion it is up to each individual Heathen to decide for themselves what is missing in their particular Heathen practice and go out and get the necessary information or experience to create or reconstruct those missing components. Ideally, once this knowledge has been gained, it would be shared  in some way with the rest of the Heathen community. Modern Heathenry can continue to grow in complexity and scope, but as with anything valuable, it takes hard work.

2016 Huginn's Heathen Hof