Folkish owned company takes stand against racism Book Review: “Norse Mythology” By Neil Gaiman History Channel’s “Vikings” has gone down hill. Loki in Fjölvinsmál: Lævateinn and Lýr Paying the Price Arizona man files suit against The Asatru Community, Heathen Talk Network, and The Troth Making Your Own Butzemann So you want to pronounce Old Norse names… Ranting Recon: ¿Cuáles son las festividades Heathen? Equality and Gender in Heathenry So you want to be a Heathen The (Other) Most Wonderful Time of the Year The Rational Heathen: Is it Time to Abandon the Irminsul? The Ancestors as Bridges Instead of Barriers Asatru Means Faith, Not Hate Heathen Spirituality Heathens Deface Historic German Landmark The Last Breath of the Old Year Exceptionally rare buckle discovered with possible depictions of Loki My Vision for Heathenry Handspinning for Beginners – Plying Yarn 12 Devotional Days of Yule The Sacred Duty of Food The Skirnismal: How (And Why) Freyr Won Gerd Canadian Heathens Spearhead Pagan Declaration Lusse – Midwife of the Sun The Rational Heathen: Getting B!%¢#-Slapped by the Gods [NSFW] Fast-growing Swedish Asatru org exposed Rare Bronze Age Petroglyph Discovered in Denmark Heathens Around The World Take a Stand With Standing Rock Sioux A Heathen’s Journey to Devotional Polytheism Over 200 Oath Rings Just Discovered in Sweden Sigyn: Lady of Oblation and Victory Alvablot and Winternights Declaration 127 The Rational Heathen: Blood Sacrifices and Other Moronic Things The Reconstructionist Method O maior inimigo de Odin – Depressão no contexto Heathen The Rational Heathen: Women’s Role in Cultures Women In Heathenry: Their Words Women in Heathenry Grief and Loss in a Heathen Context A Dedication Contract for Freya São Paulo, A Thriving Hub of Heathenry? Handspinning for Beginners – Starting to Spin Celebrating the Feast of Zisa Michigan Heathen Runs For US Congress Building a Stronger Community The Rational Heathen: When Did the AFA Join the Westboro Baptist Church? Freyja Detroit Harvest Festival: How Some Heathens Are Giving Back To Their Community Urglaawe: One of History’s Best-Kept Secrets How To Write Old Norse In Runes Is Heathenry Really Missing Something? Writer’s Block from a Heathen Perspective The Real Story Behind ‘Camp Courage’ And The AFA Offerings for the Gods, Part 3: The Jotnar New Leadership Takes A.F.A In More Bigoted Direction What You Reap is What You Sow Offerings for the Gods: The Vanir Creating Sacred Space Freyr isn’t going to Bless those PopTarts The Younger Futhark Runes: An Instructive Guide Approaching the Gods: Building The Vé “What is Valhalla, and who goes there?” The Rational Heathen: Can a Heathen Follow Christ? Deconstructing the Brisingamen Myth Urglaawe – An Introduction The Elder Futhark Runes: An Instructive Guide Heathen Families’ Summer Camp Offerings for the Gods: The Aesir ¿Tenían los vikings tótems animales? Did the Vikings Have Totem Animals? Teaching Heathenry to my Kids Odin’s Greatest Enemy, Depression in a Heathen Context Where Strong Gods Are Found Tales of Ragnarök Hail Frigga What is Forn Sed? Everyday Heathenry: Making Midsummer Heathen Marriage: Anatomy of an Oath A Step In The Right Direction? T.A.C. Takes Action. The Rational Heathen: So, What IS a Heathen, Exactly? Heathenry is a Religion of Questions Handspinning For Beginners – Pre-Drafting and Drafting Fiber Ranting Recon: Becoming The Beast Know Your Lore: The Poetic Edda Book Review: “A Dictionary of Urglaawe Terminology” Speak Now Seeress: Lore Handspinning For Beginners – An Overview of Spinning Materials Wyrd Words: Faces of Odin – Soldier, Scholar, Skald, and Skeptic Ranting Recon: No, Not ALL Reconstructionists are Idiots… The Rational Heathen: Reconstructionists are Idiots Handspinning For Beginners – Finding Your Drop Spindle Our American Folk The Rational Heathen: Is There Such a Thing as Good and Evil in Heathen Belief? Just What Does The Rök Runestone Actually Say? The Generosity of the Vanir Gods Ranting Recon: What Are The Heathen Holidays? Is Heathenry Incomplete?
800px-Extern-Relief-P1050037

The Rational Heathen: Is it Time to Abandon the Irminsul?

About

The Rational Heathen. Scientist, Engineer, Author, Writer, Skeptic, and General Curmudgeon. Occasionally I hear gods. That makes me insane, probably. Website Rationalheathen.com.

Oh, boy howdy.  I know I’m going to get flack for this post, but the question has been brewing in my mind for some time. Every time I see stylized depictions of the Irminsul, I feel uncomfortable. Not because of the original meaning of the Irminsul, but what it has grown to represent due to the blatant misappropriation by the neo-Nazis and the white supremacists.

So, before I get into the reasoning behind my question — and with all honesty, I do not have an answer to the question — let’s get into the history behind the Irminsul and why it is important to heathen beliefs.

Where the Irminsul Comes from

The Irminsul or Ermensul comes straight from the Saxons. Arguably it’s named after Irmin, a
presumably main Saxon god who is linked either with Tyr or Odin, according to early 20th century historians.This is a largely reconstructed god and may or may not have existed.  Many later scholars do not think there was such a god, instead thinking that the Irminsul was more likely a representation of Yggdrasil or the World Tree.

Dr. Karl E. H. Seigfried mentions the destruction of the Irminsul in this post, and also notes that the author who writes about it wrote the account 88 years after the fact.  He furthermore adds:

“The Saxon Poet writes that the Irminsul “was fashioned in the form of a huge column and contained a corresponding wealth of adornment,” but his account was written nearly 120 years after the destruction of the site. Such later sources must be treated with caution; sources contemporary with the Saxon war do not clarify whether the Irminsul was a carved column or a natural tree.”

So, not only do we have a questionable god, but also we don’t know if the Irminsul was a post or a tree.  And while it had a huge temple surrounding it, we really don’t have any archaeological evidence determining what it was.  While we do have one possible image of it, it is a Christian depiction and not pagan art. This piece of art appeared somewhere between the 9th and 12th centuries, most likely by an artist who had never seen an Irminsul.

The Axis Mundi, or Pillar of the World

The Irminsul, and Yggdrasil, for that matter, is a form of the axis mundi, or the pillar of the world. The concept appears time and again throughout many religions. The axis mundi is the link between the heavens and the earth, forming a bridge like the Bifrost from the mundane to the supernatural. Too many religions to name have this conduit, and the Irminsul appears to be a representation of the conduit. I tend to agree with later historians, (rightly or wrongly), that it was the Saxons’ form of the World Tree.

Corruption by the Nazis

It didn’t take long for the Nazis to point to Irminism and Wotanism as their own religions due to the evolution of Heathenry in northern Europe. A great deal of emphasis was placed on the site of Externsteine where, I kid you not, a psychic Nazi archaeologist, claimed there was an Irminsul, even though there is no physical proof of one. Look up Karl Maria Wiligut sometime. This guy created the SS logo and was a spiritual counselor for Himmler.  Fun times.

The sign of the Irminsul and the meaning had been adopted by men such as Heinrich Himmler, who was big into the occult. During these dark days, heathens saw their images such as teiwaz, othala, algiz, and sowelu become part of the Nazi symbols. The Irminsul was offered as an alternative to the Christian cross.

 

Neo-Nazi and White Supremacist Symbols

If you check out the JDL’s hate symbol database, you’ll be dismayed to find images such as othala, teiwaz, and other heathen runes to be part of the neo-Nazi symbols. You also may see something that looks like a skinhead crucified on a teiwaz rune. 

Oddly enough, it looks like an Irminsul. And I suspect it’s intentional, as is the crucified skinhead looking like a mockery of the White Christ. Although I have no love for Christianity, the blending of the two images from two different beliefs, combined with the overall hate message has left me uneasy.  (Yes, I know Odin hung himself on the World Tree for nine days, but I really think this is a Heathen and Christian blending in a perverse way.) This combined with the obvious Nazi history of the Irminsul has corrupted it to the point where I’m not certain we can ever win it back without the soiled context. Look at the swastika and tell me that it is free from the Nazi taint, even though it was an ancient rune and symbol. It’s foolish to think otherwise.

If you don’t think it is still considered by the Nazis as part of the symbolism, I’ll point to the recent vandalism at Externsteine by the neo-Nazis. They consider it part of their beliefs in a big way.

So, Where Does that Leave Us with the Irminsul?

So, where does that leave us with the Irminsul?  With all honesty, I haven’t a fucking clue. It’s the World Tree, the axis mundi, and a symbol of the Saxons. But do we use the stylized Christian depiction, or go with something else?  Do we even bother with the term Irminsul and call it the World Tree?  Given the shaky ground we’re already on historically, do we even bother with it?  Or do we take it back somehow?  Maybe others will have a better idea which way to go with it, I sure don’t.

My own instinct is to let it die and stick with the World Tree.  It may not be the best solution, but it is one I am more comfortable with.  Either that or come up with a better depiction of the Irminsul which may be more historically accurate, and less, well…, Nazi.

If you enjoyed this post, consider becoming a patron of The Rational Heathen.  For about the cost of a Starbucks’ coffee a month, you can get information not on the blog as well as early releases of the post such as this one.  There are other levels of support as well, so feel free to check it out.  What’s more, you only pay for the posts you get.  So, if I don’t produce anything, you don’t owe anything.  It’s a great way to encourage me to write, and to produce really cool things.  Join up at Patreon and become The Rational Heathen’s patron!

2016 Huginn's Heathen Hof